First, totally called that player death. I'm so sad it was Lapin, but the lesson is real... DnD after 1am never leads to good things.

That said, there's nothing like a somber quiet among the players to heighten the tension in a tough battle.

Also, a beautiful last moment for him. The tough part going forward will be to not meta-game around the info Lapin got, but it'll be what it'll be.

With a real PK on our hands, now we're really into Game of Thrones territory.

Shame they left Monterrey shackled up. I genuinely wonder what would've happened if they submitted to arrest. Or heck, if they got the pontifax, who would've been pulling the strings then?

I also still think Amethar should have avoided this by claiming he was justifiably nominated by Theo, even if his kingdom is at war. I doubt it would've changed too much, but wasn't that the whole point of re-nominating him?

Anyway, hooray fun DnD games!

Update with More Thoughts

The thing that I find really striking about this game is that the group is playing Lord of the Rings while Brennan set up Game of Thrones.

In fact, it goes even a step further. Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality (which if you haven't read, you should!) has a line which I will quote wrongly, noting that many characters don't even understand which story they're in and who the hero is, leading to lots of chaos if we can't get on the same page.

Jet and Ruby think they're in a coming of age story. Amethar thinks he's in a story about the clash of his past and future. Lapin thinks (ahem, thought) he was in a story where the Sugar Plum Fairy pulled the strings.

All of this has led to what in hindsight, as well as readily foresight, seems like unnecessary chaos. The cast even mentions this as they say things like “oh no... I think I would rush her, but oh no...”

Brennan's set up waits for them to rise to the occasion (even though politics is now out as a viable option a bit). I hope they do.

#Dimension20

Fair Warning: spoilers through episode 5.

I also make a few guesses at some things, and can't wait to see how wrong I was.

ACoC Has Copious Room for Genuine Plot Turns

Typically in an RPG, even the ones Dimension 20 has done, there's a big arc that everything gravitates to. The Big Bad Evil Guy is out there somewhere, and even if we take on a side quest here or there, there's a sense that eventually we'll have to go deal with that big Dragon / Nightmare / Mastermind that limits how far those turns can go.

In ACoC? not so.

Any of the 7 kingdoms could have any number of plots to be crowned emperor of the land (or maybe to get rid of the system altogether?). Some nations might be better suited to some strategies than others, but at the moment it doesn't look like any one big bad guy is cropping up... and that's amazing. I bet Brennan has thought through how every kingdom is going to play this event for maximum gain. That means who the players choose to ally with and how and when all matter, and could significantly change the way the story unfolds.

Which brings me to another piece I'm finding fun...

Brennan is Playing on the Weaknesses of His PC's

This is not these players' first round of DnD. It's not even their first campaign together as a group. These are professional comedians, trained in improv, and the players clearly thought the entertainment value was going to be their characters.

As such, we got a bumbling king, two comically rebellious daughters, and an aloof kid who's “really more of a seed guy than a war guy.”

And then Brennan dropped them in the heart of this mess, and they haven't figured it out at all. I don't think they've even started to grasp the shape of the cage they're in.

This has heightened the suspense so much more than normal, even in typical scenes.

For example, when Ruby and Jet, subbing in for Lapin, head on the clandestine mission with Senator Ciabatta to infiltrate a fake priest's home who has already arrested and from Ciabatta's kingdom... I was holding my breath the entire time. Not because the mission turned out to be deadly. There was one guard Ciabatta dispatched of. But rather, trying to triangulate what the heck is actually going on had me on the edge of my seat the whole time.

• What does Ciabatta really want here? The priest is already captured.
• Why did he ask for help from Candia at all? Ruby and Jet (and certainly Lapin) literally did nothing he couldn't have.
• What was this priest's game with all her blackmail? Was she working alone? Was she working with the church or against it? And if against it, than with who if not her own nation (or at least it's biggest senator)?
• Why are you letting Ciabatta take bag loads of black mail to do.... something that's non-specific?

And yet... all Ruby and Jet say at the end (because I imagine they're focusing on their characters) is “wow, he was so cool!” Uh huh. And then he magically gets “mistakenly” called out as an emperor candidate the next day, eh?

In some sense, all the characters are allowed to be this naive, perhaps with the exception of Theo and Lapin. Theo may not be politically enough in the know, but has the right level of distrust. I was hoping to see more double-agent'ing from Lapin with the church, but with a battle in the cathedral next episode, that ship might've sailed.

My point is, they were all so focused on their characters, and on the easy emperor win for Candia, that no one has explored at all what the plans are for the Meatlands, or Veggieland. Breadland, Dairyland, and the church are clearly in the game right now, but it's still so very early... assuming the PC's wise up to the game they've been dropped into at all.

In Sum

I'm having a blast this season because it's basically Game of Thrones, the good parts, except easier to tell everyone apart because they're literal food groups instead of all different white guys with beards.

I suspect Brennan might have his first PC death this season if things continue at this rate.

I'll be watching, and so should you!

#Dimension20